The Bar Rates the Judges

James Orlando

(Pierce County)
Department
1  
Served since
2000  
Biography
Pierce County website  
Ranking
Sixth of 22 (93.3% positive)

Hover over a chart to see the totals  

Criminal Law Knowledge

Positive 201
Neutral 19
Negative 4

Civil Law Knowledge

Positive 299
Neutral 25
Negative 6

Fairness

Positive 347
Neutral 43
Negative 19

Respect for Parties

Positive 356
Neutral 37
Negative 14

Respect for Attorneys

Positive 358
Neutral 39
Negative 13

Vote to re-elect?

Positive 412
Neutral 0
Negative 28

Fair and Competent?

Positive 409
Neutral 0
Negative 31
Sample Lawyer comments:
  • "This judge considers the merits of both sides from his experience with a broad range of issues from private practice."
  • "Judge Orlando has an extensive knowledge of the law but does not always apply it equally to both sides."
  • "His demeanor is of the type you would hope and expect a judge to have. He treats all parties with respect and dignity."
  • "Even if I disagree with the Judge Orlando's rulings, I believe he is fair and impartial."
  • "He is generally fair but he can take a position that is not consistent with the facts due to a bias."
Judge's response:

"I am glad to be able to serve as a Judge in Pierce County Superior Court. Our work is challenging and it is rare that all litigants are pleased with the result. My colleagues and I strive to treat people fairly, with respect, and to provide them with due process and a just result under the law."