Judge

Vicki Hogan - Superior Court judge since 1993

Ratings

By 119 attorneys

Legal ability: 3.87 (13th)

Integrity, impartiality: 3.90 (14th)

Professionalism: 3.91 (14th)

Administrative skills: 4.21 (11th)

By 39 jurors

Average rating: 4.62

Attorney comments

• "Judge Hogan is just one of my favorite judges, win or lose. Her decisions are always well-reasoned and understandable, and the only time I have ever thought she departed from the law was in going out of her way to be fair."
• "Members of a jury asked me after a trial why the judge didn't like me. They noted her apparent bias against me and my client."
• "She pays particular attention to witness testimony and is impartial to gender, race and other political issues. She is not afraid to make an unpopular decision when it is warranted by law."
• "It is well accepted that she shows bias toward Tacoma attorneys. She could be one of the very best judges around -- in any county -- but her consistent bias relegates her to being a hometown favorite only."

Judge's Response

"The citizens of Pierce County are served well with overall judicial ratings that reflect 'very good' or 'excellent' by jurors and attorneys. Meaningful comments are welcomed for continued personal growth and development. I am proud to serve and will continue to work hard for the citizens of Pierce County."