Judge

Kitty-Ann van Doorninck - Superior Court judge since 1998

Ratings

By 90 attorneys

Legal ability: 3.92 (12th)

Integrity, impartiality: 3.85 (15th)

Professionalism: 3.90 (15th)

Administrative skills: 4.27 (9th)

By 128 jurors

Average rating: 4.84

Attorney comments

• "Judge van Doorninck can be demanding, but in the best possible way. She is always fair. She is very knowledgeable about the law and is willing to make tough decisions."
• "Judge van Doorninck's abrasive and condescending demeanor toward all who appear in her courtroom (attorneys and litigants alike) frequently overshadows the appropriate and reasoned decisions she makes. Even if a decision is correct, parties and attorneys frequently leave her courtroom feeling as if they have not been heard."
• "Judge van Doorninck is an extremely diligent judge and is also extremely patient with attorneys, even at times when it is not warranted. She uses her discretion appropriately and has no agenda on the bench, which is what all judges should strive to attain."
• "She knows what she is doing but can come across in a snippy and disrespectful manner both to counsel and parties."

Judge's Response

"I am honored to serve our community as a Superior Court judge. The decisions we make are important to all who appear before us. I am proud to work alongside colleagues who demonstrate such intellect and integrity."